Continue Reading on TOI App
Open App
OPEN APP

Brain-fade moment! When Aleem Dar made an umpiring howler during India vs South Africa ODI

In a dramatic moment during a 2007 ODI between India and South Af... Read More
NEW DELHI: The cricket history has had its fair share of bizarre moments but but one incident stands out for its drama is when legendary Sachin Tendulkar caught the ball, yet umpire Aleem Dar ruled it not out during an one-day international.

The occurred in 2007 during a game between India and South Africa in Belfast, which generated significant buzz.

The atmosphere was already intense as Indian bowlers swiftly removed the South African openers.

Pace great Zaheer Khan was in excellent form. And one his delivery, which he bowled a delivery outside the off saw South African star batter AB de Villiers edging it.

The ball traveled directly to Sachin at first slip, who confidently nabbed it. The Indian players were absolutely convinced they had taken a crucial wicket, as it appeared to be a straightforward catch. However, De Villiers did not walk off the field. Instead, he stayed at the crease, awaiting the umpire's decision.

Umpire Dar was faced with a critical decision. Unfortunately, he did not see the edge and the ball's movement.

To the disappointment of the Indian team and their fans, Dar declared De Villiers not out.

The decision left Indian players in complete disbelief.



The moment was filled with confusion and frustration as their celebrations turned to murmurs of discontent.

Most observers, including De Villiers, recognized that he had edged the ball, but he chose not to walk.

The entire episode sparked debates about the spirit of the game -- whether it is the player's responsibility to own up to an edge or the umpire's job to make the call.

Despite the controversial decision, de Villiers did not capitalize on his second chance.

He ended up scoring only 15 runs before being caught behind by MS Dhoni off Sourav Ganguly's bowling.
About the Author

TOI Sports Desk

The TOI Sports Desk excels in a myriad of roles that capture the ... Read More

Start a Conversation

Post comment
Continue Reading
Follow Us On Social Media
end of article
More Trending Stories
Visual Stories
More Visual Stories
UP NEXT
Do Not Sell Or Share My Personal Information